Click to Login or Sign Up

Baptist Message

"Helping Louisiana Baptists Impact the World For Christ"

Jonah auditions (Cartoon: Beyond the Ark) Deep talk (Cartoon: Preacher’s Kids) Preacher talk (Cartoon: Joe McKeever)
  • John 3:16
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Archive
  • Cartoons
    • Joe McKeever
    • Beyond the Ark
    • Church of the Covered Dish
    • Fletch
    • Preacher’s Kids
  • Contact
  • Louisiana
  • U.S. & Intl
  • Facts & Finds
  • Culture & Society
  • Editorial

McRaney to appeal ruling in lawsuit against NAMB

September 25, 2023

By Will Hall, Baptist Message executive editor

AMORY, Miss. (LBM) – Will McRaney announced Sept. 11 his intention to appeal the Aug. 15 ruling by the U.S. District Court Northern District of Mississippi that determined his lawsuit against the North American Mission Board of the Southern Baptist Convention would force the court “to inquire into religious matters and decision-making to a degree that is simply impermissible under the Constitution and the ecclesiastical abstention doctrine.”

In a statement to The Baptist Paper, McRaney contended that the court’s decision “is built around the erroneous concept of ‘THE’ Baptist Church as a denomination like the Catholic or Methodist Church.”

Indeed, in legal filings supporting NAMB’s position, the SBC is described as “the umbrella Southern Baptist governing body over all the various groups of churches.” This contravenes the SBC’s constitution which declares it “is independent and sovereign in its own sphere” and that it “does not claim and will never attempt to exercise any authority over any other Baptist body, whether church, auxiliary organizations, associations, or convention.”

McRaney further argued that the Court’s latest ruling results in a legal determination that “a form of hierarchy” does indeed exist, and threatens the autonomy and independence of Baptist churches and entities.

NAMB, meanwhile, announced after the District Court’s Aug. 15 ruling that “as Christian ministries, NAMB and others involved in this case should be protected by the First Amendment and should not be forced to endure scrutiny and intrusive examination from the courts.”

The lawsuit likely is headed to the U.S. 5th Circuit Court of Appeals that previously voted against this same District Court when it invoked similar principles of the “ecclesiastical abstention doctrine” (a legal precedent that prevents courts from deciding matters of faith such as religious doctrine) in this case.

In 2020 the Circuit Court said the District Court prematurely ended McRaney’s lawsuit because it was not clear that this legal principle was indeed at issue and that “many of the relevant facts have yet to be developed” and concluded that “it is not clear that any of these determinations will require the court to address purely ecclesiastical questions.”

“McRaney is not challenging the termination of his employment … and he is not asking the court to weigh in on issues of faith or doctrine. …” a three-judge panel of the Circuit Court stated then. “His complaint asks the court to apply neutral principles of tort law to a case that, on the face of the complaint, involves a civil rather than religious dispute.”

Comments

Editorial

Dodgers’ Kershaw has pitch-perfect response to Pride Night

Clayton Kershaw may not have pitched Friday night, but he still made more headlines than most of his teammates. The Dodgers’ star, who happens to be an outspoken Christian, made a splash at the team’s Pride Night by putting a unique twist on Los Angeles’s gear. It was a simple but powerful statement that June will … Read More

Search

  • Trending
  • Recent
  • Must Read

Recent

Archaeologists accidentally found lost remnants of America’s first soldiers

President Trump: ‘We love you, God, and we love our great military. Protect them.’

Second gold ring found in City of David sheds light on enigmatic Hellenist era in Jerusalem

Must Read

President Trump: ‘We love you, God, and we love our great military. Protect them.’

Foundation Executive Director
Jeffrey Steed to retire

Speaker Johnson to Calvary students:

Live to make an ‘impact’

Copyright © 2025 · News Pro Theme 2.1 On Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in